There are various different genera of fish called Batfish, - marine, brakish and freshwater species. Those on
this page are also known as Spadefish (both names relate to their shape, the former to the juveniles and the latter to the adults).
Marine fish native to reefs of the Indian and western Pacific Oceans, the Platax genus of 5 species differ from other Spadefish
in that their juveniles look totally different from the adults.
Whereas the adult Longfin, Orbicular and Pinnate/Dusky look very similar and, to make ID worse,
they are variable and can change the intensity of their light and dark patterns in seconds, the vulnerable juveniles have
very long fins and each species looks very different: orange like leaves, dark with neon edges like toxic flatworms or flailing
black and white like toxic devilfish.
Most of those shown above and on this section are the Longfin Batfish (P. tiera) which,
as an adult, loses its exceptionally long fins and rounds out like the other species. The Longfin has a dark spot below
the pectoral fins but it is not always visible when the dark bands are black.
It also has a long, black bar on the edge of the anal fin - but some Orbicular also seem to have this. The largest, it grows to 60cm long
(cf. 50cm for the Orbicular and 45cm for the Pinnate/Dusky - which isn't always dusky).
Above are not the very different juvenile batfishes but subadults/immatures beginning to lose their juvenile
exceptionally long fins and round out their bodies.
Subadult.
This may be an Orbicular Batfish (P. orbicularis)?
They are all shoaling fish and all variable.
Immediately above and below are Orbicular Batfish (P. orbicularis).